GovTen
Independence, in detail

How GovTen stays honest

GovTen is published by CityData.AI, a company that sells software to local government. That is a real conflict, and the honest response is not to deny it but to build controls you can check — and to hand the enforcement to someone who does not work for us.

The disclosure

Said plainly, before anyone has to ask

CityData.AI publishes GovTen. CityData.AI also sells data and software products to cities, counties and regional agencies — including, inevitably, to agencies that appear on this list.

Two responses were available. We could have hidden the publisher behind a neutral-sounding foundation, which is common and which we regard as worse. Or we could name it, then constrain what the publisher is permitted to do with the programme. We chose the second.

The constraints below are not aspirations. Each one is either a written policy the Chair can enforce, a technical control in our systems, or a number we publish. Where a control is only a policy, we say so.

What is not controlled

Being honored will make some agencies think better of CityData. We cannot control that and will not pretend otherwise. What we can control is whether anyone at CityData is permitted to act on it — and that is what the suppression rule and the no-outreach policy exist to prevent.

Controls

The ten things we hold ourselves to

No entry fee, at any stage

Not to nominate, not to be shortlisted, not to accept. There is no paid tier and no upgrade.

Judges named before nominations close

You know who will read your entry before you decide whether to write it.

Blind first round

Agency name, jurisdiction and any vendor names are redacted before judges see an entry.

The funnel is published

Nominations received, screened out, shortlisted and honoured — as numbers, every cycle, including the cycles that go badly.

A published no-sales-outreach policy

No sales or marketing action may be triggered by, timed to, or reference a GovTen award. The honoree list is not a sales input.

The publisher is ineligible

CityData.AI cannot be nominated and no CityData employee scores an entry.

Judges see no commercial pipeline

Judges have no access to CityData's customer or prospect data, in either direction.

Procurement-triggered suppression

An agency in a live procurement with CityData is suppressed from all CityData marketing for the duration — triggered by the procurement, never by the award.

Published conflict declarations

Every judge and the Chair declare relationships that could bear on an entry. Declarations are public.

The Chair can void a category

If a category cannot be judged cleanly, the independent Chair may withhold it. That authority is written into the Charter, not granted by us.

For recipients and their counsel

Accepting an award without creating a problem

Public-sector gift rules vary by jurisdiction and some are strict. We would rather hand you the facts up front than have you discover a difficulty after the announcement.

The facts your ethics officer will want

Who gives the award
GovTen Awards, published by CityData.AI
Solicited or unsolicited
Unsolicited. No recipient pays, applies for a fee waiver, or agrees to anything in exchange.
Recipient
The agency, not the individual. The award is engraved with the agency name, not a person's name.
Declared value, Gold Award
Crystal trophy and granite base — published unit cost, under US$60 including shipping
Declared value, GovTen Award
Engraved plaque — published unit cost, under US$30 including shipping
Travel or hospitality
None offered. The ceremony is online and free.
Ongoing obligation
None. Honorees may use the badge or not, speak or not, appear in the report or not.

If your rules make the object a problem

Some jurisdictions set a zero or near-zero threshold on anything of value from a party that does business with the agency. If yours does, tell us and we will do any of the following, with no effect on the honour itself:

  • Send a certificate only, which carries no material value.
  • Send nothing physical, and record the honour on the roll alone.
  • Provide a declared-value letter for your disclosure filing.
  • Ship to a foundation or friends-of organisation where that is the appropriate recipient.

The list placement is never contingent on accepting the object. An agency that declines the trophy is honored identically.

Public records

Assume everything is disclosable

In most jurisdictions we operate in, your correspondence with us is a public record. We design on that assumption.

That means we write to agencies as though the email will be published, we do not ask for anything we would not want disclosed, and we do not send anything that would embarrass a recipient if it appeared in a records request. If you need a communication handled differently for records reasons, say so and we will adapt.

It also means the reverse: if you ever want to know what we said to whom, ask. We will send you the correspondence.

Sponsors

What a sponsor buys, and what they cannot

Sponsorship covers trophies, plaques, shipping and captioning. That is the whole purpose of it.

A sponsor gets

  • A logo position on the pages where sponsors appear
  • Named acknowledgement in the annual report and ceremony
  • Advance notice of the announcement date

A sponsor never gets

  • Any role in nominations, screening, scoring or results
  • Sight of entries, shortlists or results before publication
  • A sponsored category, a named award, or placement of any kind
  • Nominator or honoree contact details

Sponsors who sell to local government are accepted, and are subject to the same no-outreach rule as the publisher for the duration of the cycle. A sponsor that breaches it is removed and the removal is published.

Accountability

Raising a concern

If you think a result was wrong, a control was breached, or someone used GovTen to sell you something, we want to hear it — and it should not have to come to us first.

To the Chair, not to us

Concerns about judging, conflicts or results go directly to the independent Chair at an address we do not monitor. The Chair decides what to do and records the decision in writing.

chair@govten.com — monitored by the Chair only. Live once the Chair is seated.

To us, for everything else

Sales contact you did not ask for, an invoice, a misuse of the badge, or a factual error on this site.

integrity@govten.com — answered within two working days.

Our commitment on breaches

If a control on this page is breached, we publish that it was breached, what happened, and what changed as a result — in the annual report of the cycle it occurred in. Not in a quiet update.